Photo and Video Contests: Judging Criteria, Votes and Your Rights
Last reviewed · Published by GiveawayShark, run by Lorenz Scheithauer (Legal Notice)
What does a sharp photo earn you in a contest scored on storytelling? In GoDaddy's Ink Your Link Contest, none of the five weighted judging criteria mentions image quality. The business story alone counted for 30%. A photo or video contest is not a drawing. Judges score entries against published criteria, and sometimes the public votes on the finalists. The rules also decide what you give up: most ask for a broad license to your work, and many ask you to confirm that everyone shown agreed.
Judges score entries against published criteria
The Tails and Touchdowns Contest from Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company is a clean example. Entrants uploaded a photo of their pet, or of themselves with their pet. They also described how they spend game days with the pet, in 150 words or less. The contest ran from 11/04/2026 through 9:00 PM PST on 12/23/2026.
The rules list four criteria with equal weight of 25% each: creativity and/or originality, relevance to theme, photo quality and emotional impact. A panel of judges chosen by Nationwide picks the winner. The rules add: "All ties will be broken by an alternative judge chosen by Nationwide and reserved for this specific purpose."
The prize in this promotion was a Super Bowl trip with a total ARV of $7,750, according to the rules. Travel for two was included only if the winner lived more than 50 miles from the game venue. A contest prize can carry conditions like any sweepstakes prize, so read the prize section as closely as the criteria.
Weighted criteria tell you where to put the effort
Not every contest weighs its criteria equally. The Ink Your Link Contest from GoDaddy Inc. was open to active GoDaddy customers. Entrants told the story of their business and its domain. Its rules give five weights that add up to 100%. The strength and authenticity of the business story counts 30%. The meaning of the business or domain to the entrant counts 25%.
The credibility of the business concept counts 20%. The link between the business and the entrant's path as an entrepreneur counts 15%. Distinctiveness and storytelling potential count 10%. The rules say these criteria "will be used to evaluate Entrants in all phases of the Contest." In this contest, a polished photo would do little for a weak story.
Judging ran in rounds. Qualified judges selected by the administrator scored all eligible entries first. The 20 highest-scoring entries moved to a final round, where a panel of GoDaddy judges scored each one. "Each Entry's final-round score will be the average of the scores assigned by judges without a conflict of interest." Five potential winners were to be notified on or about 12/11/2026.
When the public vote decides
Some contests hand the last step to voters. The World's Unluckiest Traveler promotion from Travel Guard Group, Inc. asked for a photo or video plus a story about a travel disaster. Stories had to be typed in English and run between 500 and 3,000 characters. Photos had to be .jpg, .jpeg or .png files no larger than 20MB.
The sponsor's judges came first. Entries were "evaluated based on the equally weighted Judging Criteria," and "The judges will select eight (8) Contest Finalists." The finalists were announced on 10/26/2026. Public voting ran from 9:00 AM CDT on 10/26/2026 through 11:59 PM CDT on 11/09/2026. The finalist with the most votes won the Grand Prize. The second-highest finalist won $5,000 and the third $3,000.
So in this promotion, judges decided who was in the final eight, and popularity decided the order. Voters could cast one vote per person or email address per day. The rules say votes cast through "multiple names or email addresses and/or any other fraudulent mechanism" let the sponsor disqualify the contest entry. Asking friends to vote was allowed. Extra votes cast through fake names or email addresses, by you or by friends and family, could cost you the entry.
Sharing for votes does not earn extra entries
Voting campaigns often spill onto social media. The Travel Guard rules allow it within limits. You may invite friends to vote by sharing an entry "to your X Feed or Facebook News Feed" or by "copying a direct link to the Contest Entry and sharing it separately." The next sentence sets the limit: "Contest Entrants will not receive any additional Contest Entries for sharing it."
The same promotion had a second layer. Each vote also counted as one entry into a separate voter sweepstakes, with its winner drawn at random from the votes. The rules describe the promotion as "a Video/Photo Contest (the "Contest") component and a Voter Sweepstakes (the "Sweepstakes") component." Contest entrants compete on judging and votes. Voters enter a drawing. When you share a voting link, the people you ask are entering a sweepstakes, so point them to the rules. Social platform rules for giveaways are covered in social media giveaways.
The license you grant by entering
This is the part most entrants skip. GoDaddy's rules say that submitting an entry grants the sponsor "a nonexclusive, worldwide, perpetual, royalty-free right and license" to the entry materials. It covers reproducing, editing, publishing, broadcasting and distributing them. The license includes your name, business name, domain, logo and likeness, if they are part of the entry. The next sentence, however, gives the sponsor "the unrestricted and exclusive right" to edit, publish and use any entry content.
On ownership, the same rules contain two more lines that pull in different directions. One says: "Entrant retains ownership of the Entry and any underlying business name, domain, logo, and other intellectual property." Another says: "All Entries become the property of the Sponsor and will not be returned." If ownership matters to you, ask the sponsor which line governs before you enter. This guide cannot settle it.
Travel Guard goes further. Its license is "unlimited, worldwide, perpetual" and comes "without any consideration to you." The rules also say you may have to sign papers on request to establish "the copyrights transferred and "Moral Rights of Authors" waived under these Official Rules." Nationwide's rules say: "Once submitted, entries cannot be changed or withdrawn from the Promotion." Assume an entry, once sent, is out of your hands.
People, pets and other people's work in your entry
Rights to the people in your photo are your job. The Travel Guard rules ban entries that show any person "other than you, without permission from the third-party or a parent or legal guardian if the third-party is a minor." Entrants also warrant "that you have obtained permission from a person whose name, likeness or voice is used in the Contest Entry".
None of the three sets of rules quoted here names a specific form such as a model release. They ask for permission and for your promise that you have it. Get that permission in writing before you submit, and keep a copy with your entry files. If a sponsor later asks, you can show it.
The same logic covers animals and objects. Nationwide says: "All photo submissions must be of your own pet or you must obtain approval to post photos of any pet that is not your own." Travel Guard bans trademarks and logos owned by others without permission. It also bans any personal identification, such as license plate numbers. It also bans copyrighted material owned by others, such as photographs, paintings or images from websites, without permission.
Original work, and no AI in two contests
Each set of rules demands original work in its own words. GoDaddy entrants warrant that the "Entrant owns or has obtained all necessary rights in the Entry materials submitted". Travel Guard asks for more. Entries "must be your original work; may not have won previous awards; may not have been published previously by any other entity, including in any other creative work or on the internet". A photo you already posted widely may fail that test, so read the clause before you reuse one.
Two of the contests rule out generated images. Nationwide says: "Photo submissions must be of real pets, photos created using generative AI will be excluded." Travel Guard bars entries that are "a drawing or illustration or cartoon or created or manipulated by AI tools or software." The rules quoted here do not say where ordinary editing ends. If you are unsure whether a filter counts, ask the sponsor before you enter.
Why the contest label matters for you
A skill contest picks winners on merit. A sweepstakes picks them by chance. That legal difference is explained in sweepstakes vs. contest vs. lottery. In practice, it means effort counts in a contest, and the odds statement of a sweepstakes does not apply.
Winner paperwork looks much the same in both. Travel Guard asked potential winners to return an affidavit of eligibility and a liability and publicity release within 7 days of notification. GoDaddy's documents included consent to a confidential background check. What those forms commit you to is covered in affidavit of eligibility and release. Before you upload anything, find two clauses: the license you grant and the permission you promise. In all three contests above, both sit in the same official rules as the judging criteria, so one read covers them.
